Best Look (facial, costume): Andy Lau
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Both are pretty good actors but Andy was better in this role.
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both Andy Lau and Louis Koo were Yang Guo so it's hard to decide.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): I like both.
Overall: Andy Lau = 4, Louis Koo = 2
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Carmen Lee
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Carmen Lee
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): Carmen Lee
Overall: Idy Chan = 0, Carmen Lee = 4
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Both were great as Guo Fu but I think Gigi was slightly better.
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both were able to successfully portray Guo Fu.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): I like both actresses' portrayals.
Overall: Liu On Lai = 3, Gigi Fu = 4
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Wong Mun Yee
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both were able to successfully portray Guo Xiang.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): I am neutral to both actresses.
Overall: Wong Mun Yee = 3, Theresa Lee = 3
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Gan Pui Kuan
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both were able to successfully portray Lu Wu Shuang.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): Gan Pui Kuan
Overall: Chan Fuk Sang = 2, Gan Pui Kuan = 4
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Maggie Cheung
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both were able to successfully portray Cheng Ying.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): Maggie Cheung
Overall: Wong Oi Ming = 1, Maggie Cheung = 4
Supporting Cast: The Return of the Condor Heroes 1983
Plot: The Return of the Condor Heroes 1995 because it's truer to the novel.
Most Entertaining: The Return of the Condor Heroes 1995
The Winner (which is the best TVB adaptation?): The Return of the Condor Heroes 1983 = 3, The Return of the Condor Heroes 1995 = 8
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Both are pretty good actors but Andy was better in this role.
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both Andy Lau and Louis Koo were Yang Guo so it's hard to decide.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): I like both.
Overall: Andy Lau = 4, Louis Koo = 2
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Carmen Lee
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Carmen Lee
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): Carmen Lee
Overall: Idy Chan = 0, Carmen Lee = 4
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Both were great as Guo Fu but I think Gigi was slightly better.
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both were able to successfully portray Guo Fu.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): I like both actresses' portrayals.
Overall: Liu On Lai = 3, Gigi Fu = 4
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Wong Mun Yee
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both were able to successfully portray Guo Xiang.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): I am neutral to both actresses.
Overall: Wong Mun Yee = 3, Theresa Lee = 3
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Gan Pui Kuan
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both were able to successfully portray Lu Wu Shuang.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): Gan Pui Kuan
Overall: Chan Fuk Sang = 2, Gan Pui Kuan = 4
Best Portrayal (acting wise): Maggie Cheung
Most Faithful (to the character in the novel): Both were able to successfully portray Cheng Ying.
Personal Pick (most entertaining to watch): Maggie Cheung
Overall: Wong Oi Ming = 1, Maggie Cheung = 4
Supporting Cast: The Return of the Condor Heroes 1983
Plot: The Return of the Condor Heroes 1995 because it's truer to the novel.
Most Entertaining: The Return of the Condor Heroes 1995
The Winner (which is the best TVB adaptation?): The Return of the Condor Heroes 1983 = 3, The Return of the Condor Heroes 1995 = 8
1 comment:
Carmen lee ki terlaaluu kaakuuu
Post a Comment