
The best aspect of this adaptation is the plot since it moves at a fast pace and it's true to the novel. I think this adaptation might be the truest to the novel so far...at least for TVB since I'm not sure about the Mainland Chinese ones. There is not once a draggy moment since it follows the novel very closely and I find the plot to be easier to understand in this adaptation.
Julian Cheung: Everybody says that Julian looks too "smart" to be Guo Jing and I agree to a point. He does sometimes look smarter than Guo Jing is supposed to be, but I found Julian to be a great actor since he was also able to portrayed dumbness and slowness very well. Julian is my second choice, after Felix Wong, as Guo Jing. 5*****
Athena Chu: Athena surprised me here since she was really lovable and cute as Huang Rong. I think this is her best role to date. Although I like Barbara Yung's portrayal better, Athena is my second choice as Huang Rong. 5*****
Gallen Lo: Gallen is usually a great actor but he was a miscast in here as Yang Kang. He didn't make me believe he's Yang Kang; however, his acting was okay. Thus, he only made an okay Yang Kang. 3***
Emily Kwan: Another miscast as Mu Nian Ci since she's not pretty enough and she doesn't look soft/elegant enough. However, her acting, in a way, made up for it since she's not the worst Mu Nian Ci. 3***
Julian+Athena: There are a lot more "romantic" scenes in here and I thought Julian and Athena were cute together, but there wasn't a lot of chemistry between them. 4****
Gallen+Emily: I couldn't feel the love between them so I was always questioning if they even loved each other. 2**
Themesong by Julian Cheung and Jacqueline Ng: 2** A disappointment since I don't like it at all.
Rating: 4.5**** The second best adaptation after the 1983 one due to some bad casting decisions. I enjoyed watching this but sadly, this is constantly disliked and underrated.
No comments:
Post a Comment